Tuesday, July 7, 2020

Pandemic Rage: Is It Hitting You?

Nobody expects the covid pandemic, to paraphrase Monty Python. In the last few months, life has changed in many terrifying ways, overt and subtle, and it's packed one hell of a punch in terms of mental health.

We may see some conference papers out soon but it's likely we'll need a few years perspective before we really understand how it's affected us.

When we do, my bet is that one issue will stand out most: pandemic rage.

Since the start of 2020 we've been frightened by a invisible killer disease, inundated daily by horror stories from all over the planet, and reminded that we're helpless. With a rider threat that if covid doesn't get us, a crashing economy will.

Anger is a notification that something is wrong. Adding hopelessness and fear supercharges it, creating either revolutionary rage or spiraling horror.

I suspect that what we feel, depends on how we're triggered.

I know that when I saw the first film of George Floyd circulating on Twitter, I understood why some people support the death penalty. It's a stance that goes against my code of ethics, but for minutes, I was possessed by rage. It was quite frightening.

On another day, I read some hateful comments on FB and they really bothered me. That's unusual; I've a strong streak of arrogance mixed with optimism that functions to protect me. But at that instant, I felt chilled. For a moment, the hate out there hit me.

Why am I wittering on? Because I think too many of us act as if we're okay. Like kids who hope to fool the monster under the bed by feigning ignorance, we tell ourselves that it could be worse, that we mustn't complain, and that we'll see it through.

However, by pushing away our feelings, we're falling into classic error. As Freud pointed out, repressed feelings don't die. They are buried alive and will emerge later in uglier ways.

Today, repressed fear is fuelling "righteous zeal", the kind of anger that we tell ourselves is cool because we're only enforcing rules for everyone's good.

That kind of thinking is dangerous as it destroys respect for diversity of opinions and values, and seeks to normalise and justify violence.

Righteous zeal powered the witch trials in medieval Europe, the French and Russian Revolutions, and McCarthyism in the USA. It also created atmospheres of paralyzing fear and scapegoat populations that allowed holocausts to take place in Europe, Cambodia, and Yugoslavia.

I don't know what triggers you, but I'm monitoring my anger and taking active steps to recognise it, accept it for what it is (reaction) and deal with it carefully.

In the process, I found it useful to take a long break from social media and to unfollow and snooze all those who posted triggering content. It's not personal, it's me caring for myself.

My news stream is now limited to novels (escapist stories, not anything deep or meaningful) and cats.

In addition, me and the cats are practising our selfie taking and writing our next book.

It's not perfect, but as a short term band aid, I'm finding it excellent.

What are you doing?

And in case you haven't seen the Monty Python, here's the video

Monty Python's "Spanish Inquisition" - The Musical from StormAngel on Vimeo.

Thursday, June 4, 2020

Anger Isn't A Problem: It's A Notification

Hi there, I hope you're all safe and well during these scary times. I'm talking today about anger, a topic that some of us find a little difficult. 

I hope you enjoy it - and excuse the super long hair. My fringe is beyond my chin and I'm feeling like a Borzoi.  

This is Blesk, the Borzoi, from WikiCommons.


Friday, May 15, 2020

Spotting and Coping with Toxic Forgiveness

Image by Ulrike Leone from Pixabay
You hear it all the time, "Oh, just forgive them." Forgiveness is presented as virtuous, and as an attitude we should aspire to.

But forgiving can be toxic for you and for the community. Here's my reasoning.

#1 Example: It's Not Personal

Fiona is religious and thinks divorce is a sin. It doesn't come up in office meetings, but during break times, she will pick up the newspaper, turn to the gossip column and comment on celebrity break-ups: "Another one destined for hell."

Daisy has never bothered about Fiona's attitudes, but now she is in the middle of a divorce, she finds himself gritting her teeth every time Fiona picks up a paper. 

When Dairy confides in Kim, her boss, Kim says, "Oh, that's just Fiona. It's not personal or aimed at you. Don't rock the boat. Just forgive."

If Daisy follows Kim's advice, Fiona keeps going and Daisy becomes more and more upset. Fiona may not even realise she's hurting Daisy. 

Takeaway: If you don't speak up, people may hurt you again and again. It's more sensible to push for positive change.

Suggestion for change: if Fiona is generally speaking reasonable, Daisy can be direct, "Fiona, I'm in the middle of relationship issues. It's painful. Saying I'm going to hell is neither kind nor helpful. Also, there will be others here who are divorced too or who have loved ones who are divorced."

If Fiona is difficult, Daisy can remind Kim that management should provide leadership. Kim can quietly take Fiona aside and remind her that religion has no place in an office.

Should neither be an option, I'd suggest that with toxic co-workers and an incompetent boss, Fiona rethinks whether she wants to stay.

#2 Example: Suppressing and Avoiding Difficult Emotions

Bob got a bicycle for Christmas. When his brother John asked to borrow it to go on a camping trip, Bob really didn’t want to let his treasure out of his sight.

Also, Bob knew his brother is careless and often loses or damages his own property. But being a good brother, Bob agreed to lend John his bike.

John borrowed the bike but left it unlocked outside the tent. A passing bear stole the bike and trashed it while joyriding. (This is a blog post, so let’s have some fun with it.)

John has apologised and Bob understands it was out of John’s control. So he accepted the apology. However, he’s still steaming angry and mourning his lost bicycle.

Noting this, Bob’s dad steps in and tells Bob, “You have to forgive John with an open heart. Don’t be angry. It’s just a bike.”

What happens when Bob swallows his rage and sadness?

Takeaway: Forgiveness is a process. You can't shortcut it because ignoring emotions will come back to haunt you as depression, suppressed anger etc

Suggestion for change: emotions are notifications. Anger is a notification of injustice and sadness is a notification of loss. The family might watch this video and then have a quiet chat.

Bottom line: it’s okay for Bob to feel what he feels.

Bob’s dad is probably frightened of difficult emotions, which is why he’s sending the wrong message.

However, there is another, much more toxic version of the "Oh, you must forgive" mantra.

#3 Example: Toxic Turning The Other Cheek

Mary is deeply hurt when Dave laughs at her wish to become an engineer. It is even worse when Dave makes jokes in the classroom about Mary’s ambition.

Dave clowns about, humiliates Mary in front of their friends, and very soon the boys are teasing Mary about her dreams of becoming an engineer.

Their teacher, Britt, takes Mary aside and says, “Yes, Dave is in the wrong but he’s always that way. Be the better person, Mary, and just turn the other cheek. Forgive him.”

Britt knows Dave is in the wrong and she’s okay with it. What value does Britt put on Mary?

Takeaway: When we dismiss other people's rights, we disrespect them.

Dave is a bully. Britt knows this. Mary knows this. And yet Britt is saying that’s perfectly okay.

This is as plain as the nose on your face, and yet, we have the mantra about being the better person, about turning the other cheek.

Why are victims being told to forgive?

Why don't we tell people to change, do better?

I can think of two likely scenarios.

First, people are frightened of bullies. It is possible that Britt is scared that Dave will turn on her if she tells him off. So she won’t help Mary out of fear.

If Britt is honest, she’ll admit this. But she may feel shame and lie to Mary – and herself – about her motivations.

Second, the bigger picture is that societies are typically based on inequality. There’s always a group of people identified by sex, colour, caste, or whatever label is handy, who are exploited by the rest.

Victims are told to shut up because it is useful for the powerful that injustice continues. It's what keeps them on top.

If that’s the case, then Britt may be a flying monkey, a person who helps abusers by acting as their messenger. (The phrase comes from the Wizard of Oz. Remember the Wicked Witch of the West who uses flying monkeys to attack her enemies?) 
courtesy of Oz wiki

Flying monkeys scare or guilt victims into shutting up, either because they benefit from the injustice or because they feel it's too scary to challenge powerful people.

It's easier to side with a powerful abuser than to stand up for what is right.

Flying monkeys use lines like, “Be the better person” and “He’s loves you really” and “She doesn’t really mean it, it’s just how she is.”

Also, abusers control others by gaslighting. As discussed here: how abusers act when caught out

So when you're hurt and feel as if you should forgive, or are told to forgive, think first. I'm not saying you should analyse every little thing that happens. People mess up, and that's okay. 
 
Small things don't need to be called out, either. We all say and do things without thinking. 
 
But for deliberate or consistent issues that threaten our rights, we need to speak up, for ourselves and for others. It should be done without anger and with respect.

Note:updated 19 Nov 2022




Tuesday, April 14, 2020

When a Friend or Loved One Is Suicidal: What Can You Do If There’s No Hotline, No Doctor, No System?

SOS

With all the global chaos these last few years, we've probably all got a friend or two who we are worried about.

Most suicide guides focus on listening and calling mental health services. In the UK we have the Samaritans, for example. But what if you live somewhere that doesn't have those services?

For many people around the world, there isn't a hospital or a doctor or a mental health professional. So what do you do then?

I'm going to kick off by saying I don't have a definitive answer. I work with people in difficult situations and I have found there are no easy solutions.

I do it because life is uncertain, and I believe that if we only dealt with simple things, people in difficulty would be alone. That can't be good. Also, mental health practice is always risky; it's part of the deal.


So, what do you do? Here are five things I’ve found helpful—not perfect, but better than silence:

#1 It's damn scary when someone says they are suicidal.
So when you are scared, that's perfectly okay. You'd be a bit of a twit not to be afraid.
Breathe and accept it's part of the situation.

#2 Immediate things that you can say:

  • I'm glad you're sharing this with me
  • I'm sorry you are hurting
  • Tell me, what brought this to a head? ← and then listen
  • How can I help you?

#3 Although it's tricky, you can distract your friend from suicide by focusing on the internal coping skills your friend has.
You might start this by asking:
"Do you remember another time when you were in crisis or near it? What did you find helpful then?" ← and then listen

#4 Talk safety, not assumptions.
Identify who your friend trusts in their life who is close by and who can help: family, friends, housemates, neighbours.

This is where it gets tricky:
Be aware that in many places, asking for help can be actively dangerous.
This is especially pertinent for women and LGBTQ people. For example:

  • A woman living in a country where women have few rights may be sent to live with abusive relatives. This is because those cultures believe in 'out of sight, out of mind'.
  • If she is in an abusive environment, she may also be beaten, whipped, or jailed by the authorities simply for wanting to leave.
  • An LGBTQ person who asks for help in a country where homosexuality is illegal can be jailed, whipped, or executed. Even if they don't divulge their orientation, this fear may prevent them from seeking any kind of help—even from a family doctor or tribal healer.

Another issue is when mental health issues are perceived as a personal weakness or form of wilful stubbornness.
In these communities, seeking help results instantly in a lecture that can be summed up as,
"Say your prayers, obey your parents."

Sometimes, it comes with community shaming.
You know, because everyone loves a good shaming and it's so incredibly helpful
🙄

If you don't come from one of these places, this can be hard to believe—but it's vital that you understand and respect how dangerous the world can be for marginalized and disenfranchised people.

So, when you talk it over, be respectful and put safety first.
Usually, the person you are talking to has already tried all kinds of safe and useful reaching out.

But, supposing they can think of someone—in that case, discuss what they might say and what the person they reach out to might answer.

If it sounds good to both of you, discuss who will make the call.
Your friend may want to do it themselves, or with you on a conference call, or they may feel shy and want you to do it for them.
Whatever they want, be gentle.

If there is nobody to call and there is no doctor, hospital or other help, then keep talking until the situation de-escalates.
Then make a plan for being in touch.

For your own peace of mind, make one firm appointment to text within a few hours, otherwise you'll be on tenterhooks.
And when you text, see how things are and take it from there.

If you can, open up the network so your friend gets loving support from more than one person.

Note: this may not be possible.
Often, people who are driven to extremes by despair are alone.
So be prepared to be a sole support for some time.


Being there for someone in pain isn’t easy, but it matters.
If you’ve got ideas, stories, or questions, please see me on Facebook or LinkedIn.

Let’s help each other do better.

(Note: written April 2020, minor edits and social media links added April 2025)