Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 3, 2024

Looking For Therapy But Want Complete Privacy? Here’s What You Need To Know

How To Keep Therapy Private Note: with thanks to Chris Sansbury from Pixabay for the image.
You're under pressure. You need support. However, you're smart enough to seek therapy while protecting your career, your image, and your personal life from becoming office chatter. 

I'm a qualified psychotherapist with a master’s in counselling and a decade running an international practice across 20+ countries. Here's what I've learned about therapy privacy that most practitioners won't discuss.

Why Therapy Notes Could Destroy Your Life

Notes are useful for tracking progress. In big systems, they help if you change therapists.
But they can also wreck your life.

If you're LGBTQ in a hostile country, or in a high-stakes career, leaked notes can out you. If you're a founder prepping an IPO, they can put your deal at risk. If you're a politician or public figure, they can destroy your career.

Most therapists won't show you these notes, even when you ask. This practice is standard across the industry, though hardly reassuring for clients.

My approach: you choose. I can take no notes, take them and share with you, or take them and not share them with you. You’re the client. You decide.

👉 Read the full breakdown on therapy notes 

When 'Getting Help' Becomes Dangerous

Sometimes we feel terrible. Depression is common. But in therapy, discussions around feeling suicidal are tricky. 

In certain places, a therapist is obligated to notify the authorities if you disclose suicidal thoughts. Even if suiciding is a crime in your country. Even if you have terminal cancer.

Furthermore, the rules about self-harm are unclear. Just mentioning it leads to an automatic report in some places.

Read the small print. Your therapist agreement should spell out exactly when your privacy ends—and what happens next.

My Approach: I lived for 30+ years in places where they'd punish you for suicide or being LGBTQ, so I know the risks of getting the authorities' attention. My priority is your safety, which is why I offer personalized plans tailored to your needs. 

Before we start sessions, we discuss your mental health history. If you are at risk, we discuss what’s safe in your country. 

Usually, we see mental health crisis coming and we plan for them. But if one hits unexpectedly, and you tell me you're ending your life and refuse help, I’ll call your emergency contact. This is someone you select and approve before we begin sessions.

👉 See my therapy agreement

BetterHelp Sold and Health Assured Shared Your Secrets

Think your therapy app is safe? Think again.

BetterHelp was fined $7.8 million by the FTC for selling client data to Facebook, Snapchat, Pinterest and Criteo. You told them your deepest secrets. They turned your mental health struggles into profit..

They're not alone. Many “mental health tech” platforms harvest your data and send it to advertisers. This practice is deceptive and harmful.

In the UK, Health Assured, the country’s largest employee assistance programme, let employers and other people eavesdrop on sessions. Managers could listen in real-time to employee therapy sessions without the client's knowledge or consent. Clients were never told. As the BBC reported, this is standard practice in workplace mental health.

My approach: I won’t confirm you’re a client—even if your ex or boss asks. I don’t talk about clients. Ever. Period.
👉 Read: Can You and Your Friend See the Same Therapist?

Accreditation: A Nice Word for “I Share Your Case Notes”

The BACP is the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy, the UK's largest therapy accreditation body, and it wants you to think “accredited” means better. It actually means your therapist has to share your notes.

Notes are often emailed. Anonymised? Sometimes. But if you live in a small town, work in a niche field, or have a public-facing job, you're still exposed.

It gets worse. To keep their shiny title, accredited therapists must pay other therapists to read your notes and give feedback. It’s a pyramid scheme dressed up as professionalism.
So clients pay for therapy... then pay again with their privacy.

Oh, the BACP endorses Health Assured. 

My approach: I left the BACP. I protect your confidentiality, I don’t hand over your records to climb someone else’s ladder.
👉 Why I Quit the BACP

Want to Keep Safe? Ask These Questions:

Before your first session, get clear answers to:
•    Who sees my notes?
•    Where are they stored?
•    What happens to my information if I'm involved in legal proceedings?
•    Have you discussed another client with anyone in the last year?

If they won’t answer clearly, or the contract’s full of jargon—walk away.

How I Work Differently"
•    You choose your level of note-taking and sharing
•    Your emergency contact is someone you select in advance
•    I don't confirm client relationships to anyone, ever
•    No sharing of case details ever for supervision or accreditation
•    Plain English agreements with no hidden clauses

👉 Read My Therapy Agreement
 

Your secrets should stay secret.
If you’re paying for therapy, you deserve better than marketing schemes, email leaks, and industry excuses.
I offer confidential, affordable therapy—and I work for you, not for a boardroom or badge. 

Ready for therapy that puts your privacy first? Message me today via email ellen.whyte@gmail.com or WhatsApp: +44 7514 408143 for your free 15-minute consultation.


Note: with thanks to Chris Sansbury from Pixabay for the image.

Sunday, April 2, 2023

"May I See My Therapy Notes?" A Surprisingly Controversial Topic (And Yes, I Share – Or Take None At All If You Prefer)

Sharing therapy notes empowers clients
Empowerment is key


You're pouring your heart out and the therapist takes a note. Immediately you wonder what they've written down.

So, can you see your notes?

With me, yes. In the free 15 min chat, I ask if you want notes or not. If you say yes, I always share notes with you. We're working together, right?

I believe in empowerment and transparency. So, if I think it's important enough to note down, then we're talking it over, and you need to see it.

It's your life we're talking about.

I believe refusing to share notes damages trust and infantilises clients. However, sharing notes with clients is controversial. In fact, note taking itself is also a hot topic. 

If you prefer the listen, click on the podcast 

What Therapy Notes Are For

Mental health practitioners take notes in different ways. One common style is to note how a client acts, including emotions they show, plus the therapist's hypotheses of what is going on, action taken, progress over time, or thoughts about the session.

Notes are useful to track work and effective change. When therapists have dozens of clients, you can't expect us to remember every detail without a prompt.

Also, if staff move about, having notes mean clients don't have to start all over again with every therapist change.

In hospitals, NGOs, and companies where practitioners have bosses, several people will access and use notes. They use them to extract data, to check on how your therapist is working, and more. That's a problem, which I'll discuss in a second.

Not Sharing Notes Is Common

Hospitals and companies are typically defensive, and they're known for withholding records from their patients and clients. 

It's not just therapy notes; the fight for us to see our own medical notes has been ongoing for decades. It's why so many countries have had to actively legislate to allow us access. And even then, there are lots of arguments about it - like this piece discusses so nicely. 

As early mental health practitioners were typically also medical doctors, and many therapists work in clinics, I suspect that this issue has a strong historical legacy. Whether it is or not, many therapists refuse to share notes with clients, even although in a recent study 94% of 85 clients polled said they found it useful.

I'm hearing more colleagues talk about this, so hopefully the norm will switch to transparency and empowerment being the norm. 

And if I may suggest a hint to further the revolution: if clients refuse to work with therapist who won't share, that change will come sooner.  Money always talks 😊

When Therapy Notes Hurt Clients or Are Dangerous

Another issue is that notes can hurt clients - and I'm not thinking about my awful spelling and brute approach to grammar, either.

Seriously, notes can hurt and even kill if they are seen by a third party. Here are some simple examples I come across regularly.

  • Zul is from a poor family. He shares a laptop with three sibs. If they saw his notes and learned he was depressed, they would worry.  Worrying them would burden him and impact on his mental health.
  • Fiona is exiting a violent marriage, and her husband snoops. If he sees her therapy notes, he'll beat her into hospital or an early grave.
  • Shan is an atheist in a country where that is illegal. If people saw his therapy notes, he'd be fined, flogged and jailed as part of his 're-education'.
  • Jenn had a miscarriage and she's devastated. But if her evil ex finds out, he'll accuse her of having an abortion. As those are illegal in her country, Jenn would go to trial and if wrongfully convicted, jail.
  • Mandy and Ken are discussing an abortion in a country where that's illegal. Being discovered even thinking about it means being fired and ostracised. If they we're to decide to do it and travel to a safe place, being discovered would mean jail.
  • Rob is gay in a country where that is illegal. If anyone saw his notes, he would be executed.
  • Farah is having an affair. Adultery is illegal in her country. If she's discovered, it means flogging, fines and jail.
  • Dave likes his privacy. He simply doesn't want a record of his mental health journey.
  • Karen doesn't want anyone to know she's in therapy because her organisation believes seeing a therapist means you're unstable or weak. If people knew, she'd never be promoted. She might even be fired.

The world is a nasty place, and we can't be Pollyanas. Therapy is a safe space, and that comes with obligations.

Leaks, Data Selling and Other Privacy and Security Issues

While organisations typically document everything for many good reasons, it's also a massive problem because too many are lousy at keeping records safe. 

They are targets for hacking, and sometimes unhappy staff leak or sell patient data. Here are a few articles about recent issues - in the USA,  the UK and Australia.

Organisations themselves also choose to make money by selling client data. There are a tonne of scandals, like this one where the NHS gave information to Google which wasn't the first time either, as the same issue came up in the USA in 2019.    

As for health apps that track exercise, periods, and mental health, they are built to extract, package, and sell information. It's a huge industry, as this piece and this piece explain. 

If you're okay with selling your information, that's great. But if you are private or think it may put you in danger, it pays to be careful.

I am a private practitioner. Therefore, I make my own guidelines. My primary focus is healing in a private setting. 

I do my own paperwork. Nobody knows who my clients are. I keep client notes offline, and not on a server. I have firewalls. I do everything I can to keep notes safe.

As many of my clients are vulnerable, I offer a No Notes option

I'll ask before we start if you want notes. You can say yes or no - and I don't need a reason. It's your session and your choice. And if you start off wanting notes and then change your mind, that's okay too.

My view is this: it's your session and your life, so you pick. 

Message me today via email ellen.whyte@gmail.com or WhatsApp: +44 7514 408143 for your free 15-minute consultation.

Image by John Hain from Pixabay

Tuesday, December 20, 2022

Can You Trust Therapy Ratings? Why High Ratings Might Be a Warning Sign

What you need to know about ratings and therapy
What you need to know about ratings and therapy

Ratings are everywhere. From finding my dentist and GP to choosing a taxi or a restaurant, online reviews are the standard. Clients looking for therapists want to see them too. When they see a therapist with no ratings, they wonder if something is wrong; a therapist with lots of five-star reviews seems amazing.

It may seem counterintuitive, but if you want a good therapist, look for someone who has only a handful of ratings. This is because therapy ratings are generally misleading and often dangerous. Here’s why.

Privacy, Ethics, and The Data Minefield

We’re getting better about talking things out, but for many, mental health issues remain taboo. Working internationally, I know that being known as a person who is depressed, anxious, or seeking help can affect your livelihood. You can be passed over for promotions, and families may insist on ending relationships if they discover someone is in therapy.

It’s not fair, but it’s how things are. Decent mental health practitioners do their utmost to ensure privacy. I am focussed on keeping things super private: I do all my own paperwork. My peers worry about this, too. They fire gossiping staff and keep client records inaccessible.

This commitment means we are extremely careful with listings. Contact information is fine, but ratings are tricky because they automatically identify clients.

Your Data Is Worth Millions (Literally)

ransomware image by Pete Linforth Cyybercrime by Pete Linforth from Pixabay
Your data is worth money!

Wellness apps and big companies gather client information to share or sell it for profit. This happens all the time. BetterHelp Mental Health App was fined $7.8 million for selling client information to Facebook, Instagram, and other corporations. They are not the only ones; mental health sites do it, hospitals do it, and online services lose it on a regular basis even in countries with lots of regulation like the UK.

A happy client may fill out a private feedback form thinking it's anonymous, but a week later, the PR department or some drug company is texting or phoning with special offers. The people who design these systems do it for money; they don’t care about our ethics.

Today, therapists must have online profiles, and that means ratings. Clients expect them. It’s natural because they are focused on finding a good therapist, not on the privacy risks. Because of this, it is now part of our ethics to tell clients how reviews may affect their privacy.

The Problem with Misleading Reviews

The Nature of the Work

Psychology is a blend of art and science. Most clients are happy, but sometimes there is an occasional mismatch. Usually, we adjust the approach or I help the client find a better fit. Very occasionally, someone is unhappy. One-star unhappy. Feeling disappointed is perfectly human.

The truth is, therapy means working with people who are often in deep distress, sometimes dealing with anger, personality disorders, or addiction issues. I handle this with professionalism, care, and a good dose of patience.

Fake Reviews and Con Artists

I found my dentist and doctor through reviews Five star by mcmurryjulie from Pixabay
I found my dentist and doctor through reviews

People who are unwell can react in difficult ways when upset.  This includes stalking,accusations of mistreatment and so on. It can be quite frightening. Interestingly, it is impossible to tell a fake one-star review from a real one.

For example, a respected colleague had a perfectly proper-looking one-star review that was completely untrue. The client wrote, “he didn’t bother talking to me or listening,” when the case was, “when I demanded drugs, he talked rehab instead of offering to be my supplier.”

There's another issue, too: Con artists coerce and pay for reviews. One of the most notorious con artists in Malaysia has over 100 reviews. He runs his own ‘courses’ and ‘association,’ and if you sign up, you have to rate him at five stars. Because it’s not illegal to pretend to be a psychologist, there’s no stopping him or his friends. 

Putting it all together, mental health service reviews are a minefield.

What Can You Do?

To find a safe, ethical practitioner, I suggest:

  • Avoid extremes: Too many reviews often signals a con artist or a practitioner who prioritizes marketing over client safety. I avoid anyone who nets more than six reviews a year.
  • Look beyond the stars: Consider that some one-star reviews may be inaccurate and reflect a client’s distress, not the therapist’s competence.
  • Find their voice: If the number of reviews is reassuringly low, look for a blog or social media account. This lets you see how they think and work.
  • Test their ethics: Ask if they want a five-star review in the first session. A proper answer would be a cautious thank you, followed by a short chat about the privacy implications. If they don't offer this, run!

How I Work with Ratings

Therapy is about connecting Meeting of Minds and Connect images by John Hain from Pixabay
Therapy is about connecting

I finally listed on Google this year, in 2025, and frankly, I agonised over it. I wrote a note about privacy and told my clients about the listing. I was grateful that many shared the listing, and a few wrote reviews.

I see about 60 to 80 different clients a month and I have 6 reviews. I am still in two minds because I’m very invested in privacy, but I can't work unless I have some reviews. So I’m choosing to be grateful.

To see if my service suits you, I offer a free 15-minute first chat where we discuss your therapy goals, confidentiality, and other terms. That way, you can make an informed decision based on connection, not just stars.

Originally written in 2022 when I was practising in Malaysia. Updated in 2025 to reflect continuing global privacy and ethics issues in mental health including recent UK data scandals and misuse of client information.